Submit this form
Home News Videos Music Photos Facebook Twitter Friends Newsletter Podcasts Mobile RSS
ICC: Germain Katanga's appeal dismissed

Previous article | Next
ICC - September 25, 2009
Germain Katanga

On 25 September, 2009, the Appeals Chamber of the International Criminal Court (ICC) dismissed the appeal of Germain Katanga against Trial Chamber II’s decision of 12 June which declared his case admissible before the ICC.

In February 2009, Mr Katanga filed a motion with Trial Chamber II challenging the admissibility of the case before the ICC. He submitted, amongst other things, that the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) was able to prosecute him and that, accordingly, he should not be prosecuted before the ICC. He further submitted that the Prosecutor, when applying for a warrant of arrest, should have disclosed to the Pre-Trial Chamber certain documents indicating that Mr Katanga was under investigation in the DRC, which, he claimed, made the case inadmissible before the Court. On 12 June, the Trial Chamber rejected the challenge. The Defence appealed this decision.

Today, Judge Daniel David Ntanda Nsereko, acting as Presiding Judge, gave a summary of the Appeals Chamber’s judgment in open court. He explained each of the five grounds for appeal and the Chamber’s respective determinations:

- The Defence submitted that Trial Chamber II erred in considering that the challenge to admissibility was filed out of time and that it should have been filed prior to the “commencement of the trial”. The Appeals Chamber noted that the appellant himself acknowledged that he did not suffer any prejudice from the Trial Chamber’s allegedly erroneous interpretation of the Rome Statute, because the Trial Chamber decided to consider the merits of his admissibility challenge. Since there was no prejudice, the Appeals Chamber did not deem it necessary to consider the merits of this first ground of appeal.

- The Defence submitted that Trial Chamber II erred in considering that Pre-Trial Chamber I had determined the admissibility of the case on proper grounds, since the Prosecutor failed to disclose relevant documents concerning the attacks on Bogoro for which a warrant of arrest against Germain Katanga was requested. The Appeals Chamber considered that, were it to assess the merits of this second ground for appeal, it would, in effect, be assessing the correctness of the Pre-Trial Chamber’s decision on the warrant of arrest, and not of the decision of the Trial Chamber, which was the subject of the appeal.

- The third and fourth grounds of appeal related to compliance with the principle of complementarity, under which priority is given to national systems. The ICC complements national criminal justice systems rather than replacing them. The Appeals Chamber found that the complementarity principle, as enshrined in the Statute, strikes a balance between safeguarding the primacy of domestic proceedings vis-à-vis the ICC, on the one hand, and, on the other, the goal of the Rome Statute to “put an end to impunity”. If States do not or cannot investigate and, where necessary, prosecute, the ICC must be able to intervene. The Appeals Chamber also noted that, at the time of the admissibility proceedings in the present case, there were no proceedings against Mr Katanga in the DRC, whether for the crimes with which he is charged before this Court, or for other alleged crimes. On the contrary, the DRC has made it clear that it wished for him to be prosecuted before the ICC.

- Under the fifth ground of appeal, the Defence for Mr Katanga disputed the fact that a State can decide whether or not it is willing to prosecute international crimes “without the need to justify or explain its unwillingness”. In the opinion of the Defence, that would lead to the accused being deprived of the right to effectively challenge the admissibility of the case based on a State being unable or unwilling to prosecute. However, the Appeals Chamber considered that this argument is misconceived, and held that whether or not a case is admissible is determined by the Court, which assesses the relevant facts against the criteria of article 17 of the Statute.

For these reasons, the Appeals Chamber upheld Trial Chamber II’s decision of 12 June, 2009 and dismissed the appeal.

Germain Katanga was transferred to the ICC on 17 October 2007. The charges against him were confirmed by Pre-Trial Chamber I on 26 September 2008. He and Mathieu Ngudjolo Chui allegedly jointly committed, through other persons, crimes against humanity (murder; sexual slavery and rape) and war crimes (using children under the age of 15 to participate actively in hostilities; intentionally directing an attack against a civilian population as such or against individual civilians not taking direct part in hostilities; wilful killing; destruction of property; sexual slavery and rape). The trial in the case of The Prosecutor v. Germain Katanga and Mathieu Ngudjolo Chui is scheduled to commence on 24 November 2009.


Related articles


  1. Moise Katumbi blocked from entering DR Congo (August 3, 2018)
  2. Jean-Pierre Bemba named MLC presidential candidate (July 13, 2018)
  3. ICC Confirms 14-Year Sentence Against Thomas Lubanga (December 1, 2014)
  4. ICC Case Against Bemba Wrapping Up as Another Opens (November 12, 2014)
  5. ICC confirms war crimes charges against Bosco Ntaganda (June 10, 2014)
  6. ICC sentences Germain Katanga to 12 years (May 23, 2014)
  7. At least 60 killed as train derails in Katanga province (April 23, 2014)
  8. ICC finds Germain Katanga guilty of war crimes and crime against humanity (March 7, 2014)
  9. Rebel Leader Bosco Ntaganda Makes First Appearence Before the ICC (March 26, 2013)
  10. Bosco Ntaganda in the International Criminal Court's custody (March 22, 2013)
  11. Warlord Bosco Ntaganda Turns Himself In at US Embassy in Rwanda (March 18, 2013)
  12. International Criminal Court Acquits Mathieu Ngudjolo Chui (December 18, 2012)
  13. The M23 Rebels Want to Overthrow Kabila? Nonsense (November 28, 2012)
  14. M23 Rebels Committing War Crimes (September 11, 2012)
  15. Kagame May Face War Crimes Charges at the ICC, Says US Official (July 26, 2012)
  16. US Cuts Military Aid to Rwanda Over Support to Rebels in DR Congo (July 21, 2012)
  17. DR Congo, Rwanda Sign Pact to Fight Rebels in Eastern Congo (July 15, 2012)
  18. Thomas Lubanga sentenced to 14 years (July 10, 2012)
  19. U.S. Tells Rwanda to Stop Supporting Rebels in DR Congo (July 2, 2012)
  20. Kagame Is A Problem for The U.S. and The U.K. (June 23, 2012)
  21. ICC Prosecutor Seeks 30 Years for Thomas Lubanga (June 13, 2012)
  22. Congo Army Advances On Rebels Holdout, Says Official (June 5, 2012)
  23. Rwanda Should Stop Aiding War Crimes Suspect Bosco Ntaganda: Human Rights Watch (June 4, 2012)
  24. UN Report Accuses Rwanda of Supporting Bosco Ntaganda Rebels (May 28, 2012)
  25. ICC Prosecutor Seeks New Charges Against Ntaganda, FDLR Leader (May 14, 2012)
  26. Army Suspends Military Operations Against Ntaganda Loyalists (May 6, 2012)
  27. Kabila's Position on The Arrest of Ntaganda 'Has Not Changed' (April 13, 2012)
  28. Kabila, Army Chief of Staff head to eastern Congo to deal with defectors (April 10, 2012)
  29. DR Congo Government Warns Bosco Ntaganda He May Face Justice (April 6, 2012)
  30. Thomas Lubanga found guilty of using child soldiers (March 14, 2012)


Live TV Congo Radio en ligne Radio


Make CongoPlanet.com Your Home Page | Contact Us | About Us | ╔dition en Franšais | French Edition

© 2018 CongoPlanet.com. All rights reserved.